36 Comments
User's avatar
Celine Nguyen's avatar

I just finished Mating last night and came back to this newsletter so I could re-experience your analysis, with greater depth and appreciation. I feel intensely conflicted about the relationship between the protagonist and Denoon—and how truly ideal it is—but as a true believer in Love, I’m fundamentally very touched by all the lengths the novel goes to in trying to capture it in prose, and make a case for pursuing it. We only have one life! We can’t afford cynicism or fear when it comes to the most important part of life!

Cairo Smith's avatar

It's five in the morning and LA is up and litposting. Great piece!

Adhithya K R's avatar

I revisited this review because I wanted some inspiration for writing a review of a book whose scope feels too big for me, but now I feel like I should read "Mating" immediately.

Curiously, the first thing that came to my mind when you described Tsau was the anarchic society of Anarres in The Dispossessed, which you brought it up later in the essay. And this part felt very much like Shevek's own moral dilemma about the possibility of pure scientific pursuit in Urras as opposed to continuing in Anarres's egalitarian society that eliminated inequality but also ambition:

"The modern world may be alienating and hostile, but it is full of possibilities for intelligent and driven people that no isolated village could provide, and one has to sit with the troubling thought that eradicating some of the worst aspects of society may also sweep away some of the best."

Henry Begler's avatar

Yes totally agree, I'm sure Rush has read The Dispossessed (which I also love, incidentally)

Adhithya K R's avatar

I love The Dispossessed too!

Adam Pearson's avatar

Found it n the clearance section at 2nd and Charles. Bought because of this essay

Henry Begler's avatar

hell yeah hope you dig!

Derek Neal's avatar

Great piece. I admit I’ve been biased against this book because all the trendy lit people like it. I will give it a shot at some point now.

Also, this is pedantic, but I think relevant to the interpretation of the ending so I’ll mention it. “Je viens” means I’m coming, not I’m going. Since we would only say “I’m coming” to a person who is in the location we’re coming to, Denoon in this case, it creates the feeling that she is going to back to Tsau and that mentally she’s already there. If she had said I’m going, it’s less strong imo, because she’s still speaking to the reader and hasn’t mentally placed herself in Tsau. Of course there’s also the fact that the book is in English but Rush has put this line in French, which presents other interpretations. Not having read the book I don’t know what the significance of her speaking French is. The sexual meaning of coming is the same for “je viens” so that’s another layer, too.

Henry Begler's avatar

Oh that is great info. Being an uncultured swine I had to use google translate and I must have just misremembered but the real version is much stronger.

And yes I was biased against it for similar reasons lol, or at least skeptical in my approach. I suppose I am just a temporarily embarrassed trendy kit person at the end of the day.

Lillian Wang Selonick's avatar

This makes me want to read Mating, as I stare down the barrel of my 32nd birthday. Will come back and read the final section when I do. It’s been a minute since I’ve felt enraptured by a novel like you describe.

Henry Begler's avatar

please do! i'd love to know what you think.

Henry Oliver's avatar

It’s worth reading A Bend in the River as a companion novel to Mating.

Django Ellenhorn's avatar

Lovely ending, fitting for the novel. I actually think Mortals might clock Mating on several fronts. I'm very much in the minority here. Mating is in the end something of a rousing book. It's a novel of the beginnings of love and the terrors of its continuance, and the final page is a defibrillator smacked to the chest. Mortals is more about endings. It's fat and heavy and sad. I think it's interesting that Updike hated it.

Also, Denoon and Karen make a single brief appearance (for people saying Denoon sucks, well, he gets a kind of scorching comeuppance).

Henry Begler's avatar

You've read everything! Yeah Mortals sounds really my speed, I can't wait to read it.

Django Ellenhorn's avatar

Our tastes just have diabolical amounts of overlap! If you read Mortals and don't end up writing about it (this would be foolish) hit me up to discuss.

Mortals also has some of the best chapter titles of all time. One of them, towards the end, feels devastatingly childish, especially given the context (you'll see). It's also redolent of my distilled response to any great work of literature: I Want to Go Up There.

g.r.m.z.'s avatar

The Bellovian connection goes undiscussed, but Rush is very much an inheritor of Bellow's mantle (by way of Nabokov). Mating could be seen as a response to, or radical revision of, Henderson.

Henry Begler's avatar

It synthesizes its influences really well without being too obvious about it. Henry Oliver's essay on Mating was all about its relationship w/ Naipaul. Also Doris Lessing. There's a very funny line in Mating that I assume is meant as a wry tribute that's something like, if a man tells you his favorite book is The Golden Notebook, you are dealing with a liar sent directly from hell.

Joseph Stitt's avatar

I love the gusto of this, and your writing is always so good. I especially appreciated the moment of utopian ickfulness.

I don't think I would like *Mating* as much as you like *Mating* (please note the title case and my attempt at italics), but I do like this review. Also Botswana. I need to give Norman Rush a try.

Greg's avatar

Very nice piece. Was just thinking I needed to venture into my book-clotted attic and dig it out to finally read it. Perhaps this is the impetus I need. Makes me wonder if you have ever read the beloved-by-a-similar-class-but-for-good-reason Possession?

Henry Begler's avatar

No, but I've been meaning to! It's on my shelf right now.

Greg's avatar

I don't mean to suggest it will be as good for you as Mating, or anything, but it is somewhat of a similar vein, and very, very good in my opinion.

Henry Begler's avatar

Mating was a right place-right time-right book scenario that one can't expect to happen too often, but very very good is certainly good enough for me.

BDM's avatar

This post is 100% true to the experience of reading Mating but I feel like the fundamental problem with the way the book makes you feel is that Denoon is fucking terrible. And I don't think that's an antagonistic reading… I think he is presented as terrible! I'm never quite able to resolve this lol

Diakena's avatar

Yeah, but I sorta felt like part of the thing the book's trying to convey is how love captures us in irrational ways. The narrator's clearly really smart and reflective, and yet she kinda caves right away for Denoon and then goes on a quest across the desert and almost dies just to give it a shot. I feel like we can all relate to falling for someone who, on further thought, is neither good or good for us, but the heart wants what it wants, which gives her journey an interesting tension as she tries to intellectualize an unjustifiable passion, only to eventually have the project shown to be untenable.

Julianne Werlin's avatar

I got that vibe a bit even from this review. And, to be honest, the first block quote gave me pause!

BDM's avatar

Yeah, I think it's just sort of textual that Denoon is a bully and a bit of an intellectual fraud, etc. The narrator is so charming that we are I think a bit in love with her, and I find her thoughts about love very moving, but I don't think her relationship actually matches what she says she wants. So when I'm reading the book I feel charmed and when I'm not reading it I feel… kind of angry lol.

For the other side, though, I went on a podcast to argue with Becca about Mating a couple years ago. She is pro-Denoon and does not think he's fucking terrible: https://manifesto.fireside.fm/55

Diakena's avatar

Oh dang, this is perfect! I picked up Mating on Rothfeld's rec in her book last year, so curious to hear some other takes!

BDM's avatar

I think that Rush's next book, Mortals, is a dissection of the dark side of the Mating relationship—it's a different couple but I think it basically is about what might happen in a relationship in the long term if the couple is linked by having great sex and good conversation and a level of one-sided adoration but not much else. I kind of prefer it as a book though Mating is much more fun to read.

Alex's avatar

On paper, Mating shouldn't work on any level, it's just too high concept for its own good...and yet it's brilliant!

Lillian Wang Selonick's avatar

“But what about Jews?” is a frequent thought I have

Contarini's avatar

I have a copy of this book. So many good ones, so little time. Maybe I will move this up in the queue. Saying it may be your favorite book of all time is a consideration. I skipped the last section. No spoilers for me, thanks.

Robbie Herbst's avatar

just finished reading and came back straight to this review. I started Mating just as enthusiastic as you but flagged in the middle. Somewhere in the ‘making him get a cooler haircut’ section the shine came off the apple a bit. From ‘Strife’ onward I was back on board, but there is something about the gesampt-ness of the relationship that rubbed me the wrong way. It’s interesting to me now that you compared this to Herzog (and not Henderson, for instance). For my money, Bellow is more of an intuitive and ecstatic author (and keenly psychological). Rush reminded me much more of Iris Murdoch. Both Mating and The Sea, The Sea concern themselves with an inside-out autopsy of love, both are written in a systematic, unsparing narrative voice, and both recourse to the supernatural to bring it all together. Bellow is more flawed and more appealing to me - there’s more humility in his approach, at least for the first part of his career. If you can get past the misogyny.

That said, one great joy and frustration of this novel you didn’t really mention is the broader political context, and when I thought it was going to be a social novel of the year 1980 in Southern Africa, I was super pumped. Credit to Rush for including long discourses about socialism and the ANC, but I wish there more of that actually (I know this is illogical given my prior defense of Bellow, but whatever). Anyway, just my two cents. I would’ve read it anyway, but your review from last summer bumped it up my list. Great at the time, great to revisit!

Henry Begler's avatar

I've been meaning to read The Sea The Sea for literally ten years now, the time hasn't been right but I am quite certain I will love it. Will probably tackle Murdoch in these pages sometime soon.

I think you are right on the sensibility but there is something in the specific rhythms and the musicality of the language that reminded me of Bellow (and both, ofc, remind me of Joyce). And yes I definitely see how the relationship can be annoying, though enough people have pointed this out and it reminds me enough of my own (though I would be the narrator and my girlfriend Denoon) that it causes me to wonder-- are we actually annoying? Haha. I didn't want to get into personal essay territory but it was definitely a right place/right time/right mindset thing that caused me to fall so hard for it. Anyway, glad you enjoyed!

Robbie Herbst's avatar

You’ll probably love TSTS, I was just like a shade away from it. And most of other people’s relationships are insufferable to observe too closely, so I wouldn’t sweat it.